In the divisive landscape of belief and disbelief, “Fallen Idols: Nick and Aaron Carter” occupies a significant space. This Investigation Discovery series investigates the sexual assault allegations levied against Nick Carter of the Backstreet Boys. Through interviews with those accusing him, including Melissa Schuman from Dream, the series highlights the difficulties individuals face when they speak out against powerful figures with passionate fanbases — especially in the aftermath of the #MeToo movement.
Executive producer Michael Hirschorn and showrunner Elissa Halperin shared their insights in an in-depth interview, discussing the aggressive response from the accused, the impact of #MeToo on various industries, and the unique challenges of creating a series that delves into such controversial territory.
Hirschorn notes a shift in response from those accused of misconduct, citing an increased tendency to confront accusers aggressively, a theme “Fallen Idols” exemplifies. He also pointed out that while film and television have witnessed substantial transformation through #MeToo, the music industry lags behind in addressing its dark past and ongoing issues, particularly regarding the treatment of young women.
“You’re now seeing a new wave of people being accused who now are affirmatively going after their accusers.”
Additionally, “Fallen Idols” explores the troubled dynamics within the Carter family and the mental health and addiction struggles of Aaron Carter. The producers aim to present a full picture, accounting for the challenges of fame from the perspectives of both young men and women in the industry.
Below, the interview with the producers has been condensed for brevity but retains insights into their process, decisions, and reflections on creating this controversial docuseries. Notably, it provides an intimate account of the experiences of Nick Carter’s accusers while also showcasing perspectives from different sides, including Nick Carter’s supporters and those who knew Aaron Carter.
The complete interview offers an informative and critical perspective on these contentious issues.
The Backstreet Boys perform at the DNA World Tour in Cape Town, South Africa, on May 16, 2023. (Credit: Dereck Green/Gallo Images via Getty Images)
The conversation revealed the origins of “Fallen Idols,” noting influences such as Natasha Bowler’s previous investigations and recent legal shifts in California, which hint at a brewing second wave of #MeToo revelations. They tackled the complexity of the lawsuits surrounding the accusations, the representation of each voice, and the documentary’s portrayal of an industry that hyper-sexualized young women and the accompanying pressures faced by teen stars like Schuman.
Members of the girl group Dream in Cologne, 2001. (Credit: Fryderyk Gabowicz/picture alliance via Getty Images)
The producers also discuss the impact of social media on public discourse, noting how it has intensified division and often reduced complex conversations to polarized debates. The digital age has both facilitated and complicated the creation of “Fallen Idols” due to the vehement online backlash faced by accusers.
Aaron Carter performing in New York City, 2013. (Credit: Ilya S. Savenok/Getty Images)
In reflecting on the documentary’s potential contributions to the #MeToo conversation, the producers express a desire to promote more nuanced, empathetic dialogues about celebrity, accountability, and the long-term effects of early fame. They recognize the potential for “Fallen Idols” to spark both fervent critique and earnest discussion upon its release.
“Fallen Idols” is available to stream on Max.
Read more
about “Fallen Idols” and related topics
FAQ about “Fallen Idols” and the Issues It Addresses
- What is “Fallen Idols” about?
- “Fallen Idols” is a docuseries exploring the sexual assault allegations against Nick Carter and the challenges his accusers face, as well as the mental health and addiction struggles of his brother, Aaron Carter, against the broader backdrop of the #MeToo movement.
- Who is Melissa Schuman?
- Melissa Schuman is a former member of the girl group Dream who accused Nick Carter of rape in 2017.
- How has social media impacted the conversation around “Fallen Idols”?
- Social media has polarized reactions, escalating backlash against accusers and creating intense online debates about the allegations.
- What do the producers hope to achieve with “Fallen Idols”?
- They aim to foster nuanced discussions about the complexities of celebrity, the pressures of the music industry, and the treatment of young stars, while reflecting on the impact of the #MeToo movement.