Finn Wittrock would play Superman, according to Reddit user u/deviLz0r. Wittrock, who is well-known for his work with Ryan Murphy, has the classic American appearance, the charisma of a leading man, and the magnificent head of hair needed to play Clark Kent.
In the direct-to-video animated film Superman: Man of Tomorrow, Brett Dalton provided the voice of Parasite; Darren Criss provided the voice of the titular Kryptonian. However, Redditor u/ir Bunny believes Dalton could play Superman himself in a live-action revival.
Redditor u/pick TheProjectCore's for a Superman in a movie is Jonathan Majors. It would be an interesting acting challenge for the actor, who already portrays time-traveling bad guy Kang the Conqueror, to add DC's most potent hero to his resume.
5 out of 5
A fully rebooted DCEU with Jon Hamm as Superman, Josh Brolin as Batman, Chris Pine as Green Lantern, and Neil Patrick Harris as the Flash is what Redditor u/MonkeyOnYourMomsBack wants to see. Even the notion of a 1950s setting was mentioned.
Warner Bros. would hire David Corenswet to play Superman if Reddit user u/spacecadet2023 were in charge. Corenswet has the Clark Kent appearance and has shown he can hold his own in the streaming industry.
Redditor u/AoifeAnonymous commented on a thread regarding fan-casting a new Superman, saying, "I think Michael Ealy would be a terrific pick. He can play the dork, has the jawline, and has the baby blues (along with a wonderful smile).
5 out of 5
In a perfect world, Redditor u/DRAGONBORN05 would like Henry Cavill to continue playing Superman, but if the studio decides to recast, they would choose Tom Welling to take his place. Welling has previously successfully demonstrated his suitability for the position over a period of ten years.
In the part of Clark Kent, Redditor u/Sudden Scholar647 would cast Wolfgang Novogratz. He is well-known as a Netflix star, but he possesses the charm to succeed on the big screen.
Redditor u/tdl2024 thinks that the man behind Robb Stark could become the new man behind Clark. Richard Madden played a character very similar to Superman in the MCU’s wildly polarizing Eternals movie.
Reddit user u/deviLz0r thinks Matt Bomer would be a fantastic Superman. He would bring to the part of Man of Steel the same likeability and contagious zeal that his Chuck co-star Zachary Levi brought to the role of Shazam.