In a landmark legal decision announced Tuesday, the Privy Council in London granted two Barbuda citizens the right to challenge the construction of a controversial airstrip on their home island. This construction has drawn considerable concern for its potential threat to vulnerable ecosystems, with work beginning without legally required permits.
Residents John Mussington, a marine biologist, and Jacklyn Frank, a retired educator, initiated a lawsuit against the Antiguan and Barbudan government in July 2018. Their legal right to challenge this development was originally questioned by the government, which led to the recent appeal.
U.K. lawyer Leslie Thomas, representing the Barbudans, expressed the intention to have the already-built structures torn down following the court’s ruling, describing the situation as a “real David and Goliath battle.”
Mussington highlighted the decision’s broader implications for the citizens of Antigua and Barbuda, emphasizing the ongoing struggle with transparency and accountability regarding planning laws.
This ruling is expected to set a one-of-a-kind precedent across the Caribbean, where numerous nations confront the challenge of land protection against interests of affluent foreign developers—often following natural disasters.
Despite requests for comment, neither Prime Minister Gaston Browne’s office nor the airstrip development representatives offered any response to the legal decision.
The lengthy litigation process, as described by Sarah O’Malley of the Global Legal Action Network, often deters environmental activism. Still, O’Malley expressed hope that the ruling would streamline legal pursuits to protect the environment.
The Privy Council’s judgment permits Mussington and Frank to contest the Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court’s Court of Appeal’s verdict from April 2021, which previously denied them legal standing.
Although Antigua and Barbuda gained independence from the U.K. in 1981, its highest court of appeal remains the London-based Privy Council.
One Privy Council judge, David Hope, noted the importance of allowing environmental concerns to be voiced by individuals, even if they are not directly affected by the environmental impact.
The airport in question is part of a larger initiative which includes government partnership with U.S. multimillionaire John Paul DeJoria and the Discovery Land Co., intending to construct a luxury real estate project on the island. This project was kick-started in 2017 after Hurricane Irma necessitated a full island evacuation.
Legal objections cite the lack of environmental impact assessment and violation of local permits as key issues.
Despite the completed construction of the airstrip, legal challenges persist, as the court acknowledges the potential for requiring restoration of the construction site if the authorities acted beyond their remit.
While Mussington and Frank celebrate their legal victory, Frank remains reserved, acknowledging another pending court case related to governmental construction in a national park. Both plaintiffs are dedicated to preserving Barbudan land for future generations.
___
For further updates on Latin American news, refer to https://apnews.com/hub/latin-america
FAQ Section
- What did the Privy Council in London decide?
The Privy Council ruled that two Barbudan residents have the right to challenge the construction of an airstrip on their island — a project which is claimed to have started without the necessary permits and assessments. - Who are the main figures in this legal case?
The lawsuit was brought forward by John Mussington, a marine biologist, and Jacklyn Frank, a retired teacher, against the Antiguan and Barbudan government. - What are the implications of this ruling?
This decision could set a legal precedent across the Caribbean, empowering citizens to contest developments that pose environmental risks, even when powerful foreign investors are involved. - What construction is being challenged?
The development in question involves a controversial airport and further upscale residential and commercial projects on Barbuda initiated by U.S. billionaire John Paul DeJoria and associates. - What are the environmental concerns?
The main issues include destruction of sensitive ecosystems, lack of an environmental impact assessment, violation of local laws and permissions, and potential negative effects on the island’s groundwater supply.
Conclusion
The successful appeal by Barbudan residents John Mussington and Jacklyn Frank marks a significant juncture in Caribbean environmental and legal history. This judgment establishes a crucial precedent that empowers residents to hold their governments accountable for environmental legislations and planning laws. Celebrated for its impact on future advocacy, this ruling is simultaneously a reminder of the enduring challenges faced by those striving to conserve their natural heritage against the economic interests of powerful developers.