Despite the unpopularity of restricting legal, accessible birth control, Republicans persist in their efforts, a strategy borrowed from the playbook of convicted felon Donald Trump: persistent untruths. They lie profusely, with confidence that mainstream media’s tepid fact-checking will have little impact. House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., epitomizes this with his smug demeanor. The audacity of their deception about birth control and its future legality is astonishing. However, Democrats are actively working to expose the GOP’s elaborate deception.
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., recently prompted a Senate vote on the Right to Contraception Act, which fortifies the right to access contraceptives and for health care providers to offer contraceptive services. Despite Republican senators asserting no intention of curtailing birth control access, all but two opposed the legislation. This echoes a prior vote in the House, where only 8 Republicans supported contraception rights.
Republican opposition included a medley of fabrications and diversions which boil down to falsities. Sen. John Cornyn, R-Tex., dismissed the vote as “phony,” claiming that contraception is not currently illegal. This rationale misses the preventive aim of the vote, designed to safeguard contraceptive rights amid indications, such as those from Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, that the legality of contraception may be reevaluated now that federal abortion protections are revoked.
Sen. Katie Britt, R-Ala., propagated a bizarre mistruth by suggesting the bill would provide condoms to minors, a statement far removed from the bill’s actual content and raising questions about her understanding of adolescence and contraception.
For more political insights from Amanda Marcotte, subscribe to Standing Room Only, her newsletter.
Notorious for elevating Trump’s brazen dishonesty, Republicans, like Cornyn, are emboldened. Trump, when queried about birth control policy, vaguely referenced state autonomy, a tactic to signal his tacit support to conservative constituents, all the while his staff scrambled to contradict his implication of support for birth control restrictions. Yet, during his presidency, Trump supported measures that diminished birth control coverage through health insurance, consulted with anti-contraception advisors, and severed federal funding for family planning clinics.
The positive development is that Democrats are challenging the GOP’s web of deceit.
The subterfuge within the Republican party revolves around two primary falsehoods: denying intentions to ban birth control while narrowly defining it as condoms and rhythm method solely, and inaccurately classifying most effective contraception methods as abortion. The pace at which these lies are spun leaves fact-checkers lagging behind.
The Washington Post dissected the labyrinth of Republican misinformation, citing the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), an advocacy group pivotal in abolishing abortion rights in 2022. ADF has denied intentions to ban contraception, yet it has framed contraceptives as abortifacients within litigation, a stance intended to lay the groundwork for classifying contraception as illegal under abortion-prohibiting statutes. In contrast, the truth is that contraceptives like the pill, injection, implant, IUDs, and emergency contraception prevent fertilization, not terminate it.
These deceptive tactics by Republicans aim to tire the public and evade truth-seeking dialogue. Yet, the overwhelming narrative underscores a cohesive Republican stance against the majority of contraceptive forms.
Sen. Joni Ernst, R-Iowa, exemplifies the convoluted deception when she rationalized opposing a contraception rights bill by incorrectly categorizing Plan B emergency contraception as an abortive agent. Ernst’s statement is laden with inaccuracies: Plan B prevents ovulation – not abortion, the notion that subjective beliefs equate to factual reality, and the omission of Plan B’s similarity to birth control pills in terms of active substances and mechanism of action.
The maze of falsehoods serves to deflect and mystify, creating a daunting task for those who seek to rectify the misrepresentations. However, the essential truth remains unobscured: Republicans are actively voting against the right to birth control, signifying a fundamental disagreement with a right that most Americans presumed was resolved.
Read more
about this critical issue
Frequently Asked Questions About the Republican Approach to Contraception
What is the Right to Contraception Act?
The Right to Conception Act is a legislative measure designed to secure the individual right to obtain and use contraceptives and for healthcare providers to supply these services and related information.
How did Republicans respond to the Right to Contraception Act?
Most Republicans voted against the Right to Contraction Act, with only two GOP senators breaking ranks to support it.
What reasoning do Republicans offer for opposing the Right to Contraception Act?
Republicans employed various misleading arguments against the act. Some downplayed the necessity of the law, others mischaracterized its contents, and a few misrepresented the functionality of contraceptives.
Did Donald Trump support restrictions on birth control during his presidency?
Yes, Trump’s administration enacted policies that restricted birth control coverage under health insurance and ceased federal funding for many family planning clinics that provided birth control services.
What are some misconceptions that Republicans spread about contraceptives?
Republicans have misrepresented how contraceptives work, incorrectly claiming they function as abortifacients and conflating emergency contraception with abortion.