Former “Star Trek: The Next Generation” producer Maurice Hurley had a vision for the franchise’s big screen leap that could have pinned two legendary captains against one another. Fans are keenly aware of Hurley’s tumultuous history with the series, including his clash with actress Gates McFadden that led to her temporary dismissal. However, his return coincided with the conception of a film that ultimately took a different path.
Brannon Braga, a principal writer and producer for “Star Trek,” reminisced on the movie’s early development phase. During this period, it was common practice to simultaneously develop multiple scripts to ensure at least one viable result. Hurley crafted one concept, while Braga alongside Ron D. Moore devised another. The finalized movie credits Braga and Moore as the writers, casting Hurley’s idea aside.
However, Hurley’s vision, involving interdimensional beings inflicting chaos upon the galaxy in their quest home, was distinctive. He paralleled it with an imagery of reckless desperation:
“Like a parent dashing across a schoolyard to save their endangered toddler, trampling and injuring others in the process, only to look back at the trail of havoc wrought in their urgency,” described Hurley.
Despite its unique angle, Hurley’s pitch, which might be perceived as too dark for “Star Trek,” was never realized.
FAQ about “Star Trek Generations” Conceptual History
- Who was originally envisioned as the scriptwriters for “Star Trek Generations”?
Original plans considered two scriptwriting teams: Maurice Hurley and the duo of Brannon Braga and Ron D. Moore. - Why were two scripts commissioned for “Star Trek Generations”?
Two scripts were commissioned to ensure that at least one would be viable for production, a common strategy to avoid ending up with an unsatisfactory screenplay. - Did Maurice Hurley’s script get used for “Star Trek Generations”?
No, the script credited to Brannon Braga and Ron D. Moore was ultimately used for the film. - What was the central concept of Hurley’s script?
Hurley proposed a story about interdimensional travelers inadvertently causing destruction in their attempt to return home.
Conclusion
The development of “Star Trek Generations” marks an intriguing chapter in the saga’s history, spotlighting the behind-the-scenes decisions that shape the narratives fans ultimately see. Maurice Hurley’s compelling but unused concept illustrates the creative challenges and possibilities inherent to the “Star Trek” universe. Where Hurley’s script might have led the beloved franchise will remain an enigmatic footnote in its storied legacy.