Investigative writer Hilke Schellmann, the author of “The Algorithm,” has won an Emmy. She is direct in her judgment of AI’s possible influence on journalism: it would erode reader confidence. People look to the news for factual and verifiable information, according to Schellmann, a journalism professor at New York University and a 2022 AI Accountability Fellow at The Pulitzer Center. Her warnings about the dangers of relying too much on AI in reporting foreshadow misquotations or deceptive content creation.
The integration of AI into journalism is not just a theoretical concern but a practical reality. From using AI for research and sourcing interview subjects to automating content generation and enhancing data analysis, AI tools are becoming indispensable in newsrooms. However, concerns persist about the quality and accuracy of AI-generated content, especially in distinguishing it from original reporting.
PCMag recently explored six significant ways AI has penetrated journalism, highlighting its role in various stages of news production. These include leveraging AI-powered chatbots for information gathering, utilizing algorithms to summarize documents, and even generating article ideas. While these tools enhance efficiency, they also raise questions about transparency and journalistic integrity.
Schellmann criticizes tools like ChatGPT for their limitations, noting that they often produce singular results without the ability to verify accuracy adequately. She underscores the importance of accuracy and factual correctness in journalism, suggesting that AI tools should be rigorously evaluated against these criteria before widespread adoption.
Jonathan Soma, a data journalism professor at Columbia Journalism School, offers a nuanced perspective. He acknowledges that AI’s use in journalism does not inherently erode trust but recognizes broader societal factors at play. According to Soma, issues with reader trust in journalism stem more from social and cultural dynamics than from the integration of AI technologies.
Soma highlights AI’s inherent limitations in discerning truth and accuracy. Despite advancements in natural language processing, AI models like GPT (Generative Pre-trained Transformer) often produce responses that may be statistically plausible but lack grounding in factual accuracy. This poses challenges in using AI for tasks that require verifiable information, such as fact-checking or data analysis.
In practical terms, the incorporation of AI tools like Google Pinpoint for data extraction illustrates both the potential and pitfalls. While these tools can efficiently process large datasets and identify key information, Schellmann stresses the importance of understanding their limitations. She suggests contextualizing AI-generated insights as probabilistic rather than definitive, acknowledging the inherent biases and limitations of AI algorithms.
Both experts caution against uncritical acceptance of AI-generated content in journalism. They advocate for rigorous fact-checking and transparency in disclosing the use of AI tools to ensure accountability and maintain reader trust. Despite AI’s capacity to enhance productivity and streamline workflows in newsrooms, ethical considerations and editorial oversight remain paramount.
Looking ahead, the debate over AI’s role in journalism continues to evolve. While AI offers unprecedented opportunities for innovation and efficiency, its integration must navigate ethical, legal, and professional standards. As news organizations grapple with these challenges, maintaining journalistic integrity and transparency will be crucial in mitigating potential risks and maximizing the benefits of AI technologies.
The degree to which news organizations can successfully handle these technologies while maintaining journalistic standards will determine how AI affects journalism’s trustworthiness. Journalists may use AI’s potential to enhance reporting while preserving the credibility and ethics of their field by encouraging critical engagement and careful use of these technologies.
If you like the article please follow on THE UBJ.