Netflix Adds ‘One of the Best True Crime Series Ever’: The Pembrokeshire Murders

Netflix's Latest Addition: The Pembrokeshire Murders

Netflix has just added The Pembrokeshire Murders, a gripping true-crime thriller, to its ever-growing catalog. Based on real events, this three-part drama has already earned critical acclaim, with some calling it "one of the best true-crime series of all time." The series originally aired in 2021 on ITV, but its re-release on Netflix gives it a wider audience, including those who missed its first run.

Starring Beauty and the Beast actor Luke Evans, the series brings the chilling case of the Bullseye killer to life, taking viewers on a journey to solve the murders of two couples in the 1980s. This compelling story not only highlights the meticulous detective work behind solving the case but also brings attention to the real-life victims and their families.

A Chilling True Crime Story: The Bullseye Killer

The story centers around Detective Superintendent Steve Wilkins, played by Luke Evans, who reopens a cold case that had baffled investigators for decades. In the 1980s, a man named John William Cooper terrorized the small Welsh town of Pembrokeshire, committing a string of brutal murders. Two siblings, Richard and Helen Thomas, were the first victims, followed by Peter and Gwenda Dixon, a married couple. Despite Cooper being arrested for other crimes, it wasn't until much later that he was convicted for these murders.

One of the most bizarre twists in the investigation came when detectives matched a set of artist sketches of the suspect to a segment from a 1989 episode of the darts game show Bullseye, in which Cooper had appeared. This strange coincidence helped lead authorities to uncover the evidence needed to convict him.

A Stellar Cast and Gripping Performances

Luke Evans shines in the role of Detective Wilkins, bringing depth and authenticity to the character. His portrayal of the relentless investigator who won't rest until the case is solved is a major draw for the series. However, not all reviews were positive. Janet Street-Porter, a panellist on Loose Women, criticized Evans' performance, describing him as having "all the charisma of an ironing board" and being "wooden" in his delivery.

On the other hand, the performance of Keith Allen, who plays the killer John William Cooper, was widely praised. His portrayal of a sinister and manipulative murderer is chilling, earning him praise for bringing a disturbing sense of realism to the role. In an interview with Lorraine Kelly, Allen remarked that his role reflected how murderers "walk among us" and how anyone could be capable of committing such acts.

Real-Life Impact and Respect for the Victims

The Pembrokeshire Murders is lauded not only for its gripping narrative but also for its respectful treatment of the real-life victims of the crimes. Director Marc Evans and writer Steve Wilkins—who was also the detective in charge of solving the case—ensured the series remained as true to the actual events as possible. Wilkins, who authored the 2012 book on which the show is based, played a key role in ensuring that the victims' stories were not overshadowed by the dramatization of the investigation.

Luke Evans, who plays Wilkins, expressed his shock when he first read the real story behind the case, admitting that he hadn't been fully aware of the historical significance of the murders. "When I read it (the script), I started Googling it because I think I might have been a bit too young for it to have an impact on me when it actually did happen," he shared in an interview. "The unbelievable twists that the story takes during the investigation are mind-boggling."

The Technology Behind the Case

The case's resolution involved cutting-edge forensic science, which helped link a series of burglaries to the murders. This innovation in investigative methods played a significant role in cracking the case, and it’s depicted in detail in the show. The fact that Cooper was convicted after years of being a free man speaks to the incredible persistence of Detective Wilkins and his team.

The case was officially solved in 2011, when Cooper was finally convicted for the murders. His capture marked a significant breakthrough, not only for the victims’ families but also for the broader criminal justice system.

The Show’s Success and Critical Reception

Since its re-release on Netflix, The Pembrokeshire Murders has gained an 82% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes. The show has been praised for its compelling storytelling, the quality of its performances, and its respectful approach to the real-life crimes. Critics have hailed it as a "perfect" example of a true-crime thriller that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats while honoring the memory of the victims.

However, as with any true-crime drama, some aspects of the series have drawn criticism. The portrayal of the lead character's stoic demeanor was noted by some as lacking emotional depth. While Evans’ performance as Detective Wilkins was considered restrained, many still found his portrayal effective in showing the detective’s dedication and stoicism.

Final Thoughts: Is The Pembrokeshire Murders Worth Watching?

If you’re a fan of true-crime thrillers or detective stories, The Pembrokeshire Murders is definitely worth your time. With its fascinating plot, captivating performances, and a story grounded in real-life events, it stands out as one of the more compelling true-crime series available today.

Although not every review was glowing, the general consensus is that the show offers a gripping portrayal of a case that many thought would never be solved. For fans of crime thrillers, it’s a must-watch, especially given the fascinating real-world connections and unexpected twists that unfold as the case progresses.