MLB Draft Day 1 2025: Key Themes, Standout Picks & What Comes Next

Share
MLB Draft Day 1 2025: Key Themes, Standout Picks & What Comes Next

As Day 1 of the 2025 MLB Draft concluded, it was clear that this class isn’t marked by an obvious top-tier talent. Clubs approached the event with caution, often selecting under-slot to preserve bonus pool flexibility—a sign they’re more focused on value and depth than chasing a single franchise-altering player.

Shortstop Mania Breaks Records

A major theme: 17 shortstops selected in the first round—a new high. That surge signals strength in prep shortstop talent and may lead to positional transitions as players mature.

Surprises at the Top

  • Eli Willits, a 17-year-old switch-hitting shortstop from Oklahoma, went No. 1 overall to the Nationals. At 17 years, 216 days, he’s the youngest first-overall pick since Ken Griffey Jr.—a budget-friendly, high-upside choice.
  • Tyler Bremner, a UC Santa Barbara pitcher, landed second with the Angels. Known for his 98 mph fastball and strong off-speed arsenal, he signed below slot, freeing up cap space.
  • The Rockies made a sentimental and savvy pick, selecting Ethan Holliday at No. 4—the same franchise that drafted his father, Matt Holliday. A top-ranked prep shortstop, he brings both legacy and promise.

Compelling Storylines & Hidden Gems

  • Twin talent: Kyson and Malachi Witherspoon both got drafted on Day 1 (picks 15 and 62), continuing a rare trend of twins being taken in the same draft.
  • Corona High’s moment: The California school produced three first-round picks—including the high school arm Seth Hernandez at No. 6 and another shortstop at No. 10—making history as the first prep school with three top-50 picks.

Team-by-Team Moves

  • The Orioles used pick 19 to select Auburn catcher Ike Irish, emphasizing college bat strength.
  • The Pirates focused on arms, using top-10 and second-rounders on high school pitchers with swing-and-miss raw stuff.
  • The Angels, after taking Bremner at No. 2, stayed aggressive with three more high-velocity pitchers on Day 1—aiming for impact arms early.

Why This Draft Could Be a Gamble

With fewer can’t-miss prospects, teams are banking on scouting, intel, and development to uncover post-Day-1 diamonds. Clubs that drafted under-slot now have extra funds to pursue high-upside picks in later rounds—a strategy that might pay off big if overlooked talents emerge.

Read more